2300 W Sahara Ave, Ste 800
Las Vegas, NV 89102
Talk with a health professional who truly cares about the medical field.
M-F: 8am-5pm PST
We're ready and eager to meet your billing needs.
Las Vegas, NV 89102
Talk with a health professional who truly cares about the medical field.
We're ready and eager to meet your billing needs.
Oftentimes, insurance companies will ask money back from you because they claim to have overpaid you. This obviously this can be frustrating! Here are some of the pitfalls, and how you can avoid them:
Related guides: physical therapy denial codes (CARC/RARC), top physical therapy claim denials and patient information and benefits tips.
In medical billing, a recoupment (or overpayment offset) is when a health insurer or Medicare contractor recovers a claimed overpayment by withholding funds from your practice’s current or future claim payments rather than waiting for a separate refund check. In Original Medicare, the CMS Medicare Overpayments fact sheet (MLN006379) defines an overpayment as a payment exceeding the amount due and payable under existing laws and regulations, and CMS Medicare Financial Management Manual Chapter 3 defines recoupment as “the recovery of a Medicare overpayment by reducing present or future Medicare payments and applying the amount recouped to the indebtedness.”
Under that same CMS guidance, once an overpayment of $25 or more is determined and a Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC) sends an initial demand letter, a provider may make an immediate payment, request immediate recoupment (which offsets future claim payments and avoids Section 935(f)(2)(B) interest), submit a rebuttal within 15 calendar days (which does not stop recoupment), or appeal by filing a redetermination request. For overpayments subject to recoupment limitation (42 CFR 405.379), filing a valid redetermination request by Day 30 from the demand letter prevents standard recoupment from starting on Day 41, though simple interest begins accruing on unpaid balances on Day 31. Commercial health plans set their own contract and state-law timelines for overpayment notices, refunds, and offsets, so always verify the specific payer’s remittance advice and demand notice.
A reversal or correction on a remittance advice is not always the same event as recovery of money. In its Medicare 835 version 5010A1 instructions, CMS describes a two-step process when correction and recovery occur at different times: the first step negates the original payment and reports the corrected payment; the second reports actual recoupment.
In its J15 Part B overpayment FAQs, CGS explains that the informational negative original-payment amount and a forwarding balance do not themselves represent an offset. Its guidance identifies a WO entry beside the FCN/AR reference as evidence of an offset. These are Medicare-specific examples, not universal instructions for every insurer or remittance format. For how the 837P claim, CMS-1500 and 835 ERA fit together, see our 837P, CMS-1500 and 835 ERA overview.
Before arranging repayment, reconcile the original and corrected claims, the recovery reference, actual deposits, and any refund already sent. If the records do not agree, ask the payer to explain whether money has already been recovered; do not treat a negative claim entry alone as proof of a second recovery.
Ask the patient for all health coverage information, then verify which plan was primary for the date of service before correcting or resubmitting claims. Review the recoupment notice and the plans’ coordination-of-benefits instructions rather than assuming a newly identified insurer will pay. For Medicare patients, Medicare’s coordination-of-benefits guidance explains that the primary payer pays up to its coverage limits and the secondary payer might not cover every remaining cost.
Do not treat out-of-network status alone as an instruction to bill the patient. First check the applicable plan rules, provider agreement, remittance advice and patient protections. In Medicare secondary-payer situations, CMS instructs providers to bill Medicare after the primary payer; the remittance advice shows how much may be collected from the patient. Separate No Surprises Act protections apply to certain emergency and in-network-facility care, not automatically to every independent therapy-office visit. For related denial patterns, see how out-of-network and benefits denials are handled.
Contact the patient and the payer to verify the old policy’s termination date and any replacement policy’s effective date against the original date of service. Before sending the claim to another insurer, confirm whether that plan covered the patient and service on that date and check its submission requirements. Ask the payer to clarify any conflicting eligibility or recoupment information; do not assume a new policy covers an earlier visit.
Before moving an unpaid balance to the patient, review the applicable coverage decision, provider agreement and patient-billing protections described above. A terminated policy or an insurer you do not participate with is not, by itself, a complete patient-liability determination. Our guide to denials for coverage that has terminated covers the claim side of this problem.
Compare the recoupment notice with the fee schedule and contract terms that applied to the date of service. Ask the payer to identify the rate, effective date and calculation behind the adjustment. If you dispute the amount, follow the notice’s formal dispute or appeal instructions and keep supporting records; do not assume a telephone call alone completes an appeal.
Reconcile the claim number, date of service, remittance advice and actual deposits to determine whether the same service was paid more than once. Whether you submitted the claim twice is not, by itself, the test for whether an overpayment occurred. For Medicare, CMS defines an overpayment as payment above the amount due and includes processing and administrative errors among its causes.
If you identify a Medicare overpayment, follow the Medicare Administrative Contractor’s reporting and return process. If instead you disagree with the contractor’s overpayment determination, review the demand letter’s appeal options. Keep self-identified refunds separate from disputed demands, and reconcile any recovery already made before arranging a repayment. For other payers, check the applicable notice, contract and requirements rather than applying Medicare procedures universally.
Match the payment to the intended billing provider, claim and deposit before deciding that it belongs to someone else. Ask the payer to reconcile any mismatch and provide written correction instructions. If the funds are an identified overpayment, use the applicable reporting and repayment process; if you dispute the determination, preserve the relevant records and follow the stated dispute procedure. Track any prior offset or refund so the same payment is not returned twice.
Read the audit or records request carefully, identify the claims and dates under review, and assemble the requested clinical and billing documentation. For Medicare, CMS’s Additional Documentation Request guidance explains that review considers coverage, coding, billing and medical necessity. CMS recommends placing a copy of the request first so the records can be matched to the correct patient and claim.
Check the response deadline and submission method for the specific reviewer and review type, and retain proof of submission. Do not assume good clinical practice alone guarantees a favorable audit decision. Review the written findings and available appeal instructions if you disagree; for Medicare overpayment demands, use the contractor’s stated appeal process rather than treating a records submission as an appeal.
If the review turns into a dispute, see corrected claim, reopening or appeal: choosing the next step. Missing-records findings are explained under remark code N900, and a documentation review list is in the Medicare documentation checklist.
For the overall claim workflow, see our physical therapy billing process guide. To compare outsourced service responsibilities, review ePT Billing services.
Want help preventing recoupments before claims go out? See our physical therapy billing services, check pricing, or use the 8-minute rule calculator to check timed units.

Alex is a physical therapy billing expert, and helps physical therapists collect more revenue as owner of ePT Billing.